Black Tap Milkshakes Copycat Recipe by Modern Honey. The Sugar Bomb Milkshake is made with vanilla ice cream, cotton candy, sixlet candy pearls, lollipop, white chocolate pretzels, and whipped cream. The Salty Sweet Candy Bar Milkshake is made with ice cream of choice, M & M's. peanut butter cups, chocolate covered pretzels, hot fudge, caramels or Twix and whipped cream. These are the most heavenly milkshakes on the planet!
